19/11/2026

Mediation and Intellectual Property: Lessons from the Comparison between Europe and Japan

The EU-Japan workshop on IP mediation held on 30 October 2026 highlights the value of a multidisciplinary approach: legal, technical, economic and negotiation expertise for effective conflict management.
By Dr. Del Bene Giovanna

Introduzione

Intellectual property is a particularly interesting field for mediation. A dispute over a trade mark, patent, design or licence rarely concerns only the legal issue that emerges from the case file. Behind the contested right may lie commercial relationships, investments, technologies, markets to be preserved and relationships intended to continue.

These issues were the focus of the Workshop on Mediation in Intellectual Property Disputes, held on 30 October 2026 as part of the EU-Japan Intellectual Property Action, with representatives of European and Japanese institutions, academics, mediators and intellectual property professionals taking part. The seminar compared the experiences of the EUIPO Mediation Centre, the Japan Intellectual Property Arbitration Center (JIPAC), the Japan Patent Office (JPO) and the Patent Mediation and Arbitration Centre (PMAC) of the Unified Patent Court, complementing the institutional presentations with a discussion of actual cases.

The message that emerged from the discussion is clear: mediating an IP dispute means not merely finding an alternative to litigation, but seeking a solution capable of bringing together the law, technology and the parties’ economic interests.

Why Mediate an IP Dispute?

In her introductory presentation, Asako Wechs Hatanaka, Professor of Law at Ritsumeikan University, highlighted some of the main advantages of mediation in IP disputes: party autonomy, confidentiality, reduced time and costs, specialist expertise and the opportunity to develop a forward-looking solution.

It is precisely this last aspect that makes mediation particularly interesting.

A judicial or administrative authority is called upon to decide the issue submitted for its consideration. Mediation, by contrast, allows the parties to look beyond the individual right or proceeding.

A trade mark dispute may lead to negotiations over territories, products, terms of use or a coexistence agreement. A patent dispute may develop into a licence or a cross-licensing agreement. A conflict over royalties may become an opportunity to redefine the commercial relationship.

For a business, therefore, the outcome need not consist in establishing who is right and who is wrong, but may instead involve seeking a solution that is legally sound, technically feasible and economically sustainable.

The proposed conceptual shift is particularly interesting: from ADR understood primarily as “alternative dispute resolution” towards a more developed function of private ordering, which is particularly important when technologies, economic activities and IP portfolios take on a transnational dimension that is unlikely to coincide with the boundaries of an individual dispute before the courts.

This perspective helps explain why the issue is not simply a choice between litigation and mediation. Rather, the real question becomes which dispute resolution mechanism is best suited to the particular dispute, the parties’ interests and the outcome they wish to achieve. The concluding report referred to during the workshop likewise stresses that no means of resolving disputes is inherently superior to the others: it is the nature of the conflict and the characteristics of the parties that determine which is most appropriate.

The EUIPO Experience

The presentation by Karin Kuhl, Director of the EUIPO Mediation Centre, provided a practical illustration of this development.

EUIPO mediation is a voluntary service linked to inter partes disputes pending before the Office. It is now possible for mediation also to encompass other intellectual property rights and parallel disputes between the same parties, including those outside the European Union.

The figures presented during the workshop confirm the interest in this mechanism: the EUIPO Mediation Centre has 84 mediators with IP expertise, records a settlement rate of 70% and, for completed mediations, an overall user satisfaction level of 94%.

These figures show how mediation is taking on an increasingly tangible role in the management of IP disputes at European level.

The Japanese Model: Specialist Expertise and a Multidisciplinary Approach

The comparison with Japan offered one of the most interesting insights of the workshop.

The Japan Intellectual Property Arbitration Center (JIPAC), established in 1998 by the Japan Federation of Bar Associations and the Japan Patent Attorneys Association, specializes in alternative dispute resolution in intellectual property matters.

The composition of the mediation panel is particularly significant: under the standard JIPAC model, an attorney-at-law and a patent attorney are involved. In judicial IP mediation, by contrast, the panel comprises a judge, an attorney-at-law and an IP attorney.

This is not merely an organizational characteristic. It reflects a very practical need: an IP dispute cannot always be fully understood through legal expertise alone.

A patent may require scientific and technical knowledge; a licence calls for an understanding of royalties and the economic model; a dispute between businesses may require safeguarding a market or a collaboration intended to continue.

Specialist and complementary expertise thus become integral to the quality of mediation itself.

The Role of the JPO: Hantei

The workshop also provided an opportunity to learn about another mechanism within the Japanese system: Hantei, the advisory opinion issued by the Japan Patent Office.

This is an official JPO opinion on the scope of protection of patents, designs and trade marks. The assessment is entrusted to three administrative judges, and the presentation highlighted speed and limited costs, indicating that the procedure may be completed in as little as approximately three months, at a cost of 40,000 yen per request.

Hantei is not legally binding, but constitutes an authoritative administrative opinion that may contribute to the early resolution of IP disputes.

New Prospects: SEPs, FRAND and the International Dimension

One of the most topical issues to emerge from the discussion concerned Standard Essential Patents (SEPs). In 2026, the Tokyo District Court published new guidelines on both SEP litigation and SEP Judicial Mediation. JIPAC, although it has no mediation rules specifically dedicated to SEPs, is also seeing growing interest from patent holders.

At international level, another significant development is Japan’s accession to the Singapore Convention on Mediation: the Convention entered into force for Japan on 1 April 2024. Japan has, however, made the reservation provided for in Article 8(1)(b), making the Convention’s mechanism applicable only to the extent that the parties have agreed to the application of the Convention to the settlement agreement.

This, too, confirms the importance of incorporating the issue of enforcement of the agreement into the design of the mediation process, especially where the dispute and the related obligations have an international dimension.

Not Every Dispute Should Be Mediated

The workshop rightly avoided presenting mediation as a universal solution.

It was noted that litigation may be preferable where the rights holder primarily needs to obtain an injunction or damages for infringement. Mediation, by contrast, may be particularly effective in disputes concerning licences, software development, joint research, employee inventions or the joint management of rights, especially where an existing contractual relationship needs to be maintained, rebuilt or developed.

The case discussed concerning joint holders of IP rights is illustrative: a solution may involve one party acquiring the other’s share and subsequently granting that party a licence, or the parties retaining joint ownership while agreeing different arrangements for costs and the management of licences. These are outcomes that do not readily fit the binary logic of a judicial ruling, but can be negotiated in mediation.

The question to ask, therefore, is not simply “mediation or litigation?”, but rather “what outcome needs to be achieved?”

If an authoritative decision is required, court proceedings may be the most appropriate mechanism. If, on the other hand, the relationship between the parties needs to be redefined, mediation allows them to explore solutions that would be unlikely to find a place in a judgment.

Looking Beyond Legal Positions

A further point to emerge from the workshop concerns the ability to identify what lies behind the positions formally adopted by the parties.

In an anonymized case, several trade mark opposition and appeal proceedings involving the same parties were brought together in a single mediation. Private sessions allowed the parties to express needs and concerns underlying the individual proceedings, while an agreed timetable kept the negotiations focused. The methodological lesson is clear: address the commercial relationship behind the case files, rather than each case file in isolation.

The discussion was then developed further by showing that choosing mediation does not settle the question of which method to use in addressing the dispute.

In IP disputes, at least three dimensions need to be considered: relationships, complexity and money. Time, costs, applicable laws, languages, cultures, confidentiality, the expertise of the neutrals, and the implementation and enforcement of any resulting agreement must also be assessed.

The practical case presented is particularly telling: a dispute between a US company and an Asian company, also involving European distributors, concerned five principal patents as well as designs, software and trade marks, with proceedings already underway in numerous countries. Through online and in-person meetings and the creation of different working groups, mediation led in less than three months to a comprehensive settlement of the disputes, including coexistence and cross-licensing arrangements.

The example effectively illustrates the difference between adjudicating a dispute and resolving a conflict. A judicial decision would necessarily have addressed the claims brought in the individual jurisdictions; mediation, by contrast, was able to establish a new framework for relations between the businesses.

The Central Role of Expertise

This is probably the main lesson that the comparison between Europe and Japan offers mediators, lawyers, IP advisers and businesses.

The complexity of intellectual property disputes calls for the integration of different types of expertise:

  • mediation expertise, to bring interests to the surface and develop possible solutions;
  • legal expertise, to assess rights, obligations and the limits of the agreement;
  • technical expertise, particularly important in patent and technology disputes;
  • economic and commercial expertise, to understand royalties, licences, markets and the value of assets.

The JIPAC model makes this multidisciplinary approach particularly visible by bringing together an attorney-at-law and a patent attorney.

The EUIPO experience, from a different perspective, also highlights the importance of specialist expertise: the objective is not necessarily to reach a compromise on an individual case, but to understand the broader IP and commercial context in which the dispute arises.

Conclusione

Ultimately, the comparison between Europe and Japan invites us to move beyond a view of mediation as simply a faster or less expensive alternative to litigation.

In intellectual property matters, its added value may lie above all in its ability to develop a solution that litigation, by its nature, cannot always offer: coexistence agreements, licences, cross-licensing, the delineation of markets or new forms of collaboration.

To achieve this, however, legal expertise alone is not always enough.

An IP mediator must understand the dynamics of mediation and be able to engage with the law, technology, the value of assets and the needs of the business. In some disputes, this may also mean assembling a mediation team in which legal and technical expertise are both present and can interact effectively.

This is perhaps the most interesting lesson of the EU-Japan workshop: in IP disputes, a multidisciplinary approach is not an ancillary element of mediation, but may become one of the main factors contributing to its effectiveness.

Because good mediation should not only help the parties bring the dispute to a close but, where possible, create the conditions for generating value beyond the dispute.

 

Sources

  1. Agenda Workshop on Mediation in Intellectual Property Disputes — 30 October 2026
  2. Asako Wechs Hatanaka, Why Mediation Matters in IP Disputes – A comparative view from Japan and the EU.
  3. Karin Kuhl, Mediation at the EUIPO.
  4. Yuji Yamaguchi, Workshop on Mediation in Intellectual Property Disputes – Part 1 – Expert Presentation.
  1. Trial and Appeal Department, Japan Patent Office, “Hantei” – Advisory Opinion from JPO.
  2. Yuji Yamaguchi, Workshop on Mediation in Intellectual Property Disputes – Part 2 – Presentation of Case Examples.
  3. Julian Peter, Staeger & Sperling, A Counsel’s Perspective.
  4. Jeremy Lack, Workshop on Mediation in IP Disputes – Case Examples.

 

Condividi questo articolo su:

Facebook
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Email